The Short List – Best Pizza Places on Cape Cod


Welcome to the Short List!

The Short List is a place for people to share opinions and discover new things on and about Cape Cod. We take your feedback and thoughts and share them with readers!
We asked Cape Codders where they believe is the best pizza place place on the Cape. Thanks to all who voted! Here are the results for the best pizza places on Cape Cod!

Joey’s Pizzeria – Dennis Port

Joey’s is known for their delicious hand-tossed thin crust Italian pizza. The pizzas are made to order using only the best ingredients! In addition to great pizza you can order fresh oysters from Joey’s oyster farm! For more information on Joey’s Pizzeria, please click here.ThinkstockPhotos-161174996

Paul’s Pizza & Seafood – Falmouth

Paul’s Pizza & Seafood offers numerous pizza toppings on their buttery crusted but crispy pizzas and has a selection of seafood choices too. Custom make your own pizza or choose one of the specialty pizzas. For more information on Paul’s Pizza & Seafood, please click here.

Pizza Prima – Mashpee

Pizza Prima makes their pizzas with quality ingredients that are both fresh and tasty. Pick-up and delivery is available or you can eat at the family friendly restaurant that offers fast service in a casual atmosphere. For more information on Pizza Prima, please click here.

Pizza Barbone – Hyannis

Pizza Barbone features wood fired pizzas utilizing fresh ingredients for natural flavor. Pizza Barbone is unique in that it has a Stefano Ferrara wood fired oven. This oven is one of 30 in the country and is a custom hand made oven crafted from rock and ash from Mt. Vesuvius. For more information on Pizza Barbone, please click here.ThinkstockPhotos-490267007

B&B Pizza – Hyannis

B&B Pizza does delivery and pick-up, but you can also eat inside or at the bar. They offer specialty pizzas and regular pizzas that can come in small or large. There are big screen TVs to watch sports with friends and you can come in and grab a slice to go for a quick snack. For more information on B&B Pizza, please click here.

Jack’s Pizza – Hyannis

Family owned, Jack’s Pizza is close to downtown Hyannis and is easily accessible. Delivery is available and specials are served daily. Stop by Jack’s for good drink and a bite to eat with friends. For more information on Jack’s Pizza, please click here.

Spiritus Pizza – Provincetown

Scrumptious pizza with friendly and efficient service. Spiritus also serves ice cream and is a great place to go for a bite to eat while in Provincetown. For more information on Spiritus Pizza, please click here.Pizza

Wicked Restaurant & Wine Bar – Mashpee

Locally owned, the Wicked Restaurant offers hand crafted artisan pizzas, salads, seafood and burgers. Wicked uses only organic ingredients for its fire kissed pizzas and serves lunch and dinner and provides a gluten-free menu. For more information on Wicked Restaurant & Wine Bar, please click here.

Palio Pizzeria – Hyannis

Palio Pizzeria serves thin-crust pizza using homemade Neapolitan style dough and has a number of specialty pizzas and southern Italian style meals including sandwiches and sweet treats. You can craft your own pizza or get a brick oven grinder or some pasta. For more information on Palio Pizza, please click here.

Notable Mentions:

  • Craigville Pizza
  • Dennis Port House of Pizza
  • Two Brothers
  • Pizza Guyz
  • Toly’s House of Pizza
  • Paradise Pizza
  • George’s
  • Regina’s Pizzeria
  • Sweet Tomatoes
  • Grill 500
  • The Red Barn Pizza
  • Dino’s
  • Taki’s
  • Fazio’s
  • Pizza by Evan
  • Bass River Pizza
  • Torino
  • Rose & Vicki’s
  • Zia’s

Take a look at some of our past Short List topics!



  1. Pizza by Evan is the worst Pizza in the world.

  2. Beverly Tilden says

    Where is Siena? The best!

Speak Your Mind

737 West Main Street
Hyannis, MA 02601
Contact Us | Advertise Terms of Use 
Employment and EEO | Privacy